Quick answer
A contractor can withdraw an offer before acceptance, but that does not automatically preserve the EMD or bid security. The outcome turns on the tender’s bid-validity, forfeiture and security-instrument clauses.
- A bidder may revoke an offer before acceptance, but an express tender clause can still permit forfeiture when the bid is withdrawn during its validity period.
- Read the bid-validity period, the precise forfeiture triggers, the amendment and withdrawal procedure, and the security format before sending any withdrawal communication.
- A bid bond can be an accepted form of bid security in eligible Central Government procurement, but the tender’s wording still determines whether withdrawal creates a claim risk.
A contractor can withdraw a tender offer before it is accepted, but Supreme Court bid security forfeiture in India is a reminder that withdrawal can still trigger loss of EMD or enforcement of the tender security. In National Highway Authority of India v. Ganga Enterprises, the Supreme Court held that the right to withdraw an offer did not by itself create a right to recover bid security where the tender separately allowed forfeiture for withdrawal during the bid-validity period. Read the Supreme Court judgment and the tender clauses before applying that principle to a current tender.
The practical question is not simply whether the offer can be revoked. It is whether the bidder agreed, through the tender conditions, to keep the bid open and accept forfeiture if it withdraws, changes the offer, or fails to complete the next steps. This guide discusses the Supreme Court’s judgment dated 28 August 2003 and a later 2021 decision on the importance of the notice inviting tender and letter of award. It is general information, not legal advice. A withdrawal decision should be reviewed against the actual tender pack, corrigenda, submitted bid and security instrument.
What the Supreme Court decided about bid security forfeiture in India
In NHAI v. Ganga Enterprises, the specific tender required a ₹50 lakh bid security, applicable to that 1997 toll-collection tender, and stated that it could be forfeited if the bidder withdrew during the bid-validity period or, after notification of acceptance, failed to furnish performance security or sign the agreement. The bid had to remain valid for 120 days after the last date for bid submission. The bidder furnished an on-demand bank guarantee and withdrew before that 120-day period ended. The Supreme Court held that the right to withdraw an offer did not create a right to get the bid security back where the bidder had agreed to a separate forfeiture condition. Read the full Supreme Court judgment and tender clauses.
The distinction matters. Under Section 5 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a proposal may be revoked before communication of acceptance is complete against the proposer. But the Court treated bid security as an assurance for the bidder’s separate commitment not to withdraw during the stated validity period and, if selected, to furnish the next security and sign the agreement. That is why an earnest money forfeiture on tender withdrawal can follow even when the offer itself is withdrawn before acceptance.
The ruling is not a blanket licence to take every EMD. The tender in that case expressly set out the amount, security form, bid-validity period and events that allowed forfeiture. Start with those provisions in your own tender, not with a headline about the case.
Can a contractor withdraw a tender without losing bid security?
Sometimes, but only if the tender documents and the facts allow it. A contractor should not assume that a pre-acceptance withdrawal is cost-free. The key question is whether the withdrawal occurs within the bid-validity period and whether the tender expressly identifies withdrawal, modification or failure to take a post-award step as a forfeiture event.
For Central Government procurement covered by Rule 170 of the General Financial Rules, bid security, also called earnest money, is intended to protect against a bidder withdrawing or altering its bid during the bid-validity period. The rule also permits a bid securing declaration, under which withdrawal or modification can lead to suspension from future bids rather than a monetary security claim. See the Department of Expenditure’s current General Financial Rules, updated through 31 January 2026.
Before deciding to withdraw, identify which of these positions applies:
- The bid-validity period has not expired. Withdrawal may fall squarely within a forfeiture clause.
- The bidder wants to correct a commercial, technical or arithmetic point. The tender may treat modification in the same way as withdrawal after the submission deadline.
- A letter of acceptance or award has been issued. The tender may make failure to furnish performance security, sign the agreement or complete other conditions a separate forfeiture trigger.
- The tender calls for a bid securing declaration instead of EMD. The consequence may be suspension or another stated procurement sanction, rather than encashment of a security instrument.
- The bid-validity period has expired without a valid extension. Check the tender’s extension mechanism and all correspondence before treating the bid as open or closed.
Do not send an informal email saying that the bid is no longer viable until the tender manager, finance team and counsel have reviewed the documents. A poorly framed request for clarification or revised pricing may be characterised as a withdrawal or non-compliance if the tender language supports that result.
Why the purpose and wording of the tender security matter
The Supreme Court in Ganga Enterprises focused on what the bid security was for. It was not security for performance of the future toll-collection contract. It was security for keeping the bid open during validity and, after acceptance, for providing performance security and signing the agreement. The judgment records the exact bid-security and bid-validity clauses.
That purpose should guide your document review. Look beyond the label “EMD”, “bid security” or “earnest money”. Check the operative language:
- Trigger: Does the clause say “may be forfeited” or “shall be forfeited”? Which acts trigger it: withdrawal, modification, misrepresentation, refusal of award, non-submission of performance security, or failure to sign?
- Time window: Is the trigger limited to the original bid-validity period, an extension accepted by the bidder, or a specified period after award?
- Authority and process: Who may decide on forfeiture? Does the tender require notice, an explanation, or a written determination?
- Instrument wording: For a bank guarantee or bond, does the beneficiary need to state a specified breach? Is the instrument payable on demand? Is the instrument amount capped?
- Consequences beyond money: Does the tender also provide for disqualification, debarment, suspension or reporting under an integrity framework?
In South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. v. S. Kumar’s Associates AKM (JV), decided on 23 July 2021, the Supreme Court examined the NIT and letter of award to determine whether a concluded contract existed. On the terms before it, failure to furnish performance security and complete required documentation led to cancellation of the award and forfeiture of bid security, rather than recovery of the procurer’s claimed differential cost. The Supreme Court’s judgment shows why the exact sequencing and wording of the tender documents are decisive.
What contractors should check before withdrawing a bid
Use a short decision file. It gives management a clear record and helps avoid a withdrawal that inadvertently widens the exposure.
- Freeze the tender record. Save the NIT or RFP, all addenda, bidder queries, portal acknowledgements, submitted bid, bid-security receipt or instrument, and bid-validity extensions.
- Map dates. Record bid submission, validity expiry, extension acceptance, technical opening, price opening, selection notice and any deadline for performance security or contract signing.
- Identify the actual trigger. State whether the proposed step is withdrawal, amendment, inability to honour quoted terms, refusal of award, or a request for extra time. These are not necessarily treated alike.
- Read the security instrument separately. Its beneficiary, amount, expiry, claim procedure and wording may not mirror the tender clause exactly.
- Check whether a compliant correction route exists. Some tenders permit clarifications, but a clarification process should not be used to change an offer unless the tender permits it.
- Assess the commercial exposure. Include the security amount, future eligibility consequences, project capacity, subcontract commitments and the cost of performing at the submitted price.
- Approve the communication centrally. The withdrawal letter should come from an authorised signatory and should accurately identify the tender, bidder entity and reason for the request.
If the issue is the form of security rather than the decision to withdraw, consider whether the tender accepts a bid bond for tender security. Confirm acceptance with the procuring entity from the tender itself. Do not assume that a security form accepted in one authority’s tender will be accepted in another.
How a bid bond changes the tender-security process
A bid bond is an insurance surety bond used as tender security where the procurement terms accept it. Rule 170 of the General Financial Rules permits bid security for Central Government procurement to be provided in forms including insurance surety bonds, bank guarantees and other specified instruments. The current Rule 170 framework also recognises a bid securing declaration as an alternative in the circumstances set out in the rule. The insurance surety bond option was inserted through a Department of Expenditure amendment dated 2 February 2022, as reflected in the rule’s amendment notes.
The operational change is in the instrument, not in the bidder’s tender undertaking. A bid bond can replace a cash deposit or bank guarantee only where the tender accepts it and the bond meets the required format, value and validity. The tender’s forfeiture or claim provisions still define the events that can expose the bidder.
Review these points before arranging a bond:
- the tender’s approved security forms and prescribed format;
- the beneficiary name, tender reference, sum insured or bond amount, and validity plus claim period;
- the conditions under which the beneficiary may make a claim;
- whether amendments, extensions or bid-validity renewals require a corresponding bond endorsement; and
- the applicant’s financial information and indemnity commitments required by the underwriter.
Insurance is subject to the bond and policy terms. Eligibility, collateral requirements and terms depend on the applicant’s financials and the tender. You can review how the surety bond process works before applying, or compare a surety bond with a bank guarantee as part of your tender-finance review.
What to document when a bid withdrawal becomes necessary
Document the reason quickly, but do not confuse speed with an admission of a contractual breach. Preserve a factual chronology and obtain approvals before the communication is sent.
Your file should contain the error or change that led to the decision, when it was discovered, calculations or technical reports supporting it, internal approval notes, all tender correspondence and portal screenshots, and the final withdrawal notice with proof of delivery. If the bidder has received a letter of acceptance or award, include the response deadline, performance-security requirement and signing requirements.
The external communication should be precise. Identify the tender and bid reference, state the action being taken, reserve rights where appropriate, and avoid unnecessary explanations that contradict the bid record. If the procuring entity indicates that it will forfeit or invoke the security, compare its stated ground with the specific tender clause and the security wording before responding.
For a bid bond, notify the relevant parties promptly and provide the complete tender record. The bond wording and the tender terms both matter to the handling of any demand. If you need to plan the security before bid submission, discuss your tender security requirement.
FAQ: Can forfeited bid security be challenged in India?
Can forfeited bid security be challenged in India?
Yes, but the starting point is the tender package. A challenge may turn on whether the tender clearly authorised forfeiture for the event relied on, whether the bid was still valid, whether the bidder actually took the action alleged, and whether the procuring entity followed the applicable tender framework. The Supreme Court’s analysis in Ganga Enterprises favoured enforcement because the forfeiture conditions were express and the withdrawal was within the agreed validity period. See the full decision.
Can a bidder withdraw before acceptance and still lose EMD?
Yes. Section 5 recognises revocation before acceptance is complete, but the Supreme Court has held that this does not itself undo a separate bid-security undertaking. Where the bidder accepted a clause requiring the bid to remain open for a fixed period and allowing forfeiture for early withdrawal, that contractual consequence can apply. Read Section 5 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 with the tender clause and security instrument.
Does a bid bond eliminate the risk of tender withdrawal?
No. A bid bond may be an accepted form of bid security for a tender, but it does not change the agreed withdrawal, modification or post-award conditions. Check the tender’s permitted forms and prescribed format, then ensure the bond’s amount and validity match the requirement. Rule 170 includes insurance surety bonds as an accepted form of bid security within the Central Government procurement framework described there. See the current Rule 170 text.
A bid withdrawal should be treated as a contract and finance decision, not just a portal action. Read the tender terms first, preserve the record, and get advice on the specific facts before you communicate with the procuring entity.
Ask Assurety whether a bid bond may fit the tender’s security requirements and request a quote. Eligibility and terms depend on the tender and the applicant’s financials.
Frequently asked questions
Can forfeited bid security be challenged in India?
It may be challenged where the tender terms do not clearly authorise forfeiture for the event in question, the stated trigger did not occur, or the procuring entity has acted outside the tender framework. The result depends on the tender, correspondence and security wording. Obtain advice promptly before expiry or invocation steps.
Can a bidder withdraw a tender before it is accepted?
Section 5 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 permits revocation of a proposal before acceptance is complete against the proposer. However, the Supreme Court has distinguished that right from the separate contractual consequence of forfeiting bid security when a bidder agreed to keep its bid open for a stated validity period.
Does using a bid bond prevent bid-security forfeiture?
No. A bid bond changes the permitted form of security where the tender accepts it. It does not remove a tender clause that makes withdrawal, modification, failure to sign, or failure to provide performance security a trigger for action against the bid security.


